| Ray Hooker | 165 lbs. | 1929 |
| Mal McDonald | 121 lbs. | 1942 |
| Mark Matovina | 128 lbs. | 1942 |
| Frank Ruggieri | Hwt. | 1942 |
| Waldermar Van Cott | 175 lbs. | 1947 |
| Ray Gunkel | Hwt. | 1947 |
| Arnold Plaza | 114.5 lbs. | 1948 |
| Waldermar Van Cott | 175 lbs. | 1948 |
| Arnold Plaza | 121 lbs. | 1949 |
| Waldermar Van Cott | 175 lbs. | 1949 |
| Arnold Plaza | 121 lbs. | 1950 |
| Joe Patacsil | 128 lbs. | 1950 |
| Charles Farina | 135 lbs. | 1950 |
| Charles Moreno | 145 lbs. | 1950 |
| Al Vega | 123 lbs. | 1954 |
| Vernon Whitney | 123 lbs. | 1956 |
| Ahmet Senol | 191 lbs. | 1956 |
| Dominic Fatta | 147 lbs. | 1960 |
| Bob Marshall | 157 lbs. | 1960 |
| Bob Marshall | 167 lbs. | 1961 |
| Dave Gibson | 147 lbs. | 1962 |
| Bob Hopp | Hwt. | 1964 |
| Joe Corso | 126 lbs. | 1975 |
| Alan Housner | 150 lbs. | 1975 |
| Bernie Barrile | 167 lbs. | 1975 |
| Dave Lilovich | 158 lbs. | 1985 |
| Dave Lilovich | 158 lbs. | 1986 |
| Scott Hinkel | 126 lbs. | 1987 |
| Joe Urso | 167 lbs. | 1987 |
| Mike McHenry | 177 lbs. | 1989 |
| Dave Walter | 158 lbs. | 1990 |
| Dave Walter | 158 lbs. | 1991 |
| Charles Jones | 167 lbs. | 1991 |
| Matt Lindley | Hwt. | 1991 |
| Charles Jones | 167 lbs. | 1992 |
| Aaron Moran | 158 lbs. | 1994 |
| Tony Vaughn | Hwt. | 1994 |
| Frank Laccone | 134 lbs. | 1995 |
| Frank Laccone | 134 lbs. | 1996 |
| Tim Dernlan | 118 lbs. | 1998 |
| Eric Douglas | 158 lbs. | 1998 |
| Jason Silverstein | 125 lbs. | 1999 |
| Jake Vercelli | Hwt. | 2001 |
| Chris Fleeger | 125 lbs. | 2002 |
| Jake Vercelli | Hwt. | 2002 |
| Chris Fleeger | 125 lbs. | 2003 |
| Ryan Lange | 174 lbs. | 2003 |
| Ryan Lange | 174 lbs. | 2004 |
| Ben Wissel | 184 lbs. | 2005 |
| Chris Fleeger | 133 lbs. | 2006 |
| Ben Wissel | 184 lbs. | 2006 |
| Jake Patacsil | 149 lbs. | 2009 |
| Cashé Quiroga | 125 lbs. | 2010 |
|
|
