| Year |
Result |
| 2012
| (6) Purdue 79, (11) Nebraska 61 |
|
| (3) Ohio State 88, (6) Purdue 71 |
| 2011
| (7) Michigan State 74, (2) Purdue 56 |
| 2010
| (2) Purdue 69, (7) Northwestern 61 |
|
| (6) Minnesota 69, (2) Purdue 42 |
| 2009
| (3) Purdue 79, (6) Penn State 65 |
|
| (3) Purdue 66, (2) Illinois 56 |
|
| (3) Purdue 65, (5) Ohio State 61 |
| 2008
| (10) Illinois 74, (2) Purdue 67 (OT) |
| 2007
| (5) Purdue 74, (4) Iowa 55 |
|
| (1) Ohio State 63, (5) Purdue 52 |
| 2006
| (6) Michigan State 70, (11) Purdue 58 |
| 2005
| (7) Iowa 71, (10) Purdue 52 |
| 2004
| (10) Minnesota 62, (7) Purdue 52 |
| 2003
| (5) Michigan State 54, (4) Purdue 42 |
| 2002
| (9) Iowa 87, (8) Purdue 72 |
| 2001
| (8) Purdue 91, (9) Minnesota 77 |
|
| (1) Illinois 83, (8) Purdue 66 |
| 2000
| (6) Wisconsin 78, (3) Purdue 66 |
| 1999
| (10) Michigan 79, (7) Purdue 73 (OT) |
| 1998
| (3) Purdue 76, (6) Indiana 71 |
|
| (3) Purdue 68, (2) Illinois 47 |
|
| (4) Michigan 76, (3) Purdue 67 |
